<< Chapter < Page Chapter >> Page >

The situation would seem different to the astronaut. Because motion is relative, the spaceship would seem to be stationary and the Earth would appear to move. (This is the sensation you have when flying in a jet.) If the astronaut looks out the window of the spaceship, she will see time slow down on the Earth by a factor of γ = 30 . 0 size 12{γ="30" "." 0} {} . To her, the Earth-bound sister will have aged only 2/30 (1/15) of a year, while she aged 2.00 years. The two sisters cannot both be correct.

There are two sections in this figure. In the first section a young woman is shown standing on the Earth and her twin is standing in a traveling spaceship. There is a clock beside each of the women showing equal time. In the second section of the figure it is shown that the traveling twin ages less than the Earth-bound twin and the Earth-bound twin is looking older. In the clocks it is shown that on Earth time runs faster than on the traveling spaceship.
The twin paradox asks why the traveling twin ages less than the Earth-bound twin. That is the prediction we obtain if we consider the Earth-bound twin’s frame. In the astronaut’s frame, however, the Earth is moving and time runs slower there. Who is correct?

As with all paradoxes, the premise is faulty and leads to contradictory conclusions. In fact, the astronaut’s motion is significantly different from that of the Earth-bound twin. The astronaut accelerates to a high velocity and then decelerates to view the star system. To return to the Earth, she again accelerates and decelerates. The Earth-bound twin does not experience these accelerations. So the situation is not symmetric, and it is not correct to claim that the astronaut will observe the same effects as her Earth-bound twin. If you use special relativity to examine the twin paradox, you must keep in mind that the theory is expressly based on inertial frames, which by definition are not accelerated or rotating. Einstein developed general relativity to deal with accelerated frames and with gravity, a prime source of acceleration. You can also use general relativity to address the twin paradox and, according to general relativity, the astronaut will age less. Some important conceptual aspects of general relativity are discussed in General Relativity and Quantum Gravity of this course.

In 1971, American physicists Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating verified time dilation at low relative velocities by flying extremely accurate atomic clocks around the Earth on commercial aircraft. They measured elapsed time to an accuracy of a few nanoseconds and compared it with the time measured by clocks left behind. Hafele and Keating’s results were within experimental uncertainties of the predictions of relativity. Both special and general relativity had to be taken into account, since gravity and accelerations were involved as well as relative motion.

1. What is γ size 12{γ} {} if v = 0 .650 c size 12{v=0 "." "150"c} {} ?

Solution

γ = 1 1 v 2 c 2 = 1 1 ( 0 . 650 c ) 2 c 2 = 1 . 32 size 12{γ= { {1} over { sqrt {1 - { {v rSup { size 8{2} } } over {c rSup { size 8{2} } } } } } } = { {1} over { sqrt {1 - { { \( 0 "." "650"c \) rSup { size 8{2} } } over {c rSup { size 8{2} } } } } } } =1 "." "32"} {}

2. A particle travels at 1 . 90 × 10 8 m/s size 12{1 "." "90" times "10" rSup { size 8{8} } `"m/s"} {} and lives 2 . 10 × 10 8 s size 12{2 "." "10" times "10" rSup { size 8{ - 8} } `s} {} when at rest relative to an observer. How long does the particle live as viewed in the laboratory?

Δ t = Δ t 0 1 v 2 c 2 = 2 . 10 × 10 8 s 1 ( 1 . 90 × 10 8 m/s ) 2 ( 3 . 00 × 10 8 m/s ) 2 = 2 . 71 × 10 8 s size 12{Δt= { {Δt rSub { size 8{0} } } over { sqrt {1 - { {v rSup { size 8{2} } } over {c rSup { size 8{2} } } } } } } = { {2 "." "10" times "10" rSup { size 8{ - 8} } " s"} over { sqrt {1 - { { \( 1 "." "90" times "10" rSup { size 8{8} } " m/s" \) rSup { size 8{2} } } over { \( 3 "." "00" times "10" rSup { size 8{8} } " m/s" \) rSup { size 8{2} } } } } } } =2 "." "71" times "10" rSup { size 8{ - 8} } " s"} {}

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Section summary

  • Two events are defined to be simultaneous if an observer measures them as occurring at the same time. They are not necessarily simultaneous to all observers—simultaneity is not absolute.
  • Time dilation is the phenomenon of time passing slower for an observer who is moving relative to another observer.
  • Observers moving at a relative velocity v size 12{v} {} do not measure the same elapsed time for an event. Proper time Δ t 0 size 12{Δt rSub { size 8{0} } } {} is the time measured by an observer at rest relative to the event being observed. Proper time is related to the time Δ t size 12{Δt} {} measured by an Earth-bound observer by the equation
    Δ t = Δ t 0 1 v 2 c 2 = γ Δ t 0 ,

    where

    γ = 1 1 v 2 c 2 .
  • The equation relating proper time and time measured by an Earth-bound observer implies that relative velocity cannot exceed the speed of light.
  • The twin paradox asks why a twin traveling at a relativistic speed away and then back towards the Earth ages less than the Earth-bound twin. The premise to the paradox is faulty because the traveling twin is accelerating. Special relativity does not apply to accelerating frames of reference.
  • Time dilation is usually negligible at low relative velocities, but it does occur, and it has been verified by experiment.

Conceptual questions

Does motion affect the rate of a clock as measured by an observer moving with it? Does motion affect how an observer moving relative to a clock measures its rate?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

To whom does the elapsed time for a process seem to be longer, an observer moving relative to the process or an observer moving with the process? Which observer measures proper time?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

How could you travel far into the future without aging significantly? Could this method also allow you to travel into the past?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Problems&Exercises

(a) What is γ size 12{γ} {} if v = 0 . 250 c size 12{v=0 "." "250"c} {} ? (b) If v = 0 . 500 c size 12{v=0 "." "500"c} {} ?

(a) 1.0328

(b) 1.15

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

(a) What is γ size 12{γ} {} if v = 0 . 100 c size 12{v=0 "." "100"c} {} ? (b) If v = 0 . 900 c size 12{v=0 "." "900"c} {} ?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Particles called π size 12{π} {} -mesons are produced by accelerator beams. If these particles travel at 2 . 70 × 10 8 m/s size 12{2 "." "70" times "10" rSup { size 8{8} } `"m/s"} {} and live 2 . 60 × 10 8 s when at rest relative to an observer, how long do they live as viewed in the laboratory?

5 . 96 × 10 8 s size 12{5 "." "96" times "10" rSup { size 8{ - 8} } " s"} {}

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Suppose a particle called a kaon is created by cosmic radiation striking the atmosphere. It moves by you at 0 . 980 c size 12{0 "." "980"c} {} , and it lives 1 . 24 × 10 8 s when at rest relative to an observer. How long does it live as you observe it?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

A neutral π size 12{π} {} -meson is a particle that can be created by accelerator beams. If one such particle lives 1 . 40 × 10 16 s as measured in the laboratory, and 0 . 840 × 10 16 s when at rest relative to an observer, what is its velocity relative to the laboratory?

0.800 c

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

A neutron lives 900 s when at rest relative to an observer. How fast is the neutron moving relative to an observer who measures its life span to be 2065 s?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

If relativistic effects are to be less than 1%, then γ size 12{γ} {} must be less than 1.01. At what relative velocity is γ = 1 . 01 size 12{γ=1 "." "01"} {} ?

0 . 140 c size 12{0 "." "140"c} {}

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

If relativistic effects are to be less than 3%, then γ size 12{γ} {} must be less than 1.03. At what relative velocity is γ = 1 . 03 size 12{γ=1 "." "03"} {} ?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

(a) At what relative velocity is γ = 1 . 50 size 12{γ=1 "." "50"} {} ? (b) At what relative velocity is γ = 100 size 12{γ="100"} {} ?

(a) 0 . 745 c size 12{0 "." "745"c} {}

(b) 0 . 99995 c size 12{0 "." "99995"c} {} (to five digits to show effect)

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

(a) At what relative velocity is γ = 2 . 00 size 12{γ=2 "." "00"} {} ? (b) At what relative velocity is γ = 10 . 0 size 12{γ="10" "." 0} {} ?

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Unreasonable Results

(a) Find the value of γ size 12{γ} {} for the following situation. An Earth-bound observer measures 23.9 h to have passed while signals from a high-velocity space probe indicate that 24.0 h size 12{"24" "." 0" h"} {} have passed on board. (b) What is unreasonable about this result? (c) Which assumptions are unreasonable or inconsistent?

(a) 0.996

(b) γ size 12{γ} {} cannot be less than 1.

(c) Assumption that time is longer in moving ship is unreasonable.

Got questions? Get instant answers now!

Questions & Answers

tree physical properties of heat
Bello Reply
tree is a type of organism that grows very tall and have a wood trunk and branches with leaves... how is that related to heat? what did you smoke man?
what are the uses of dimensional analysis
Racheal Reply
Dimensional Analysis. The study of relationships between physical quantities with the help of their dimensions and units of measurements is called dimensional analysis. We use dimensional analysis in order to convert a unit from one form to another.
Emmanuel
meaning of OE and making of the subscript nc
ferunmi Reply
can I ask a question
Negash
kinetic functional force
Moyagabo Reply
what is a principal wave?
Haider Reply
A wave the movement of particles on rest position transferring energy from one place to another
Gabche
not wave. i need to know principal wave or waves.
Haider
principle wave is a superposition of wave when two or more waves meet at a point , whose amplitude is the algebraic sum of the amplitude of the waves
arshad
kindly define principal wave not principle wave (principle of super position) if u can understand my question
Haider
what is a model?
Ella Reply
hi
Muhanned
why are electros emitted only when the frequency of the incident radiation is greater than a certain value
ANSELEM Reply
b/c u have to know that for emission of electron need specific amount of energy which are gain by electron for emission . if incident rays have that amount of energy electron can be emitted, otherwise no way.
Nazir
search photoelectric effect on Google
Nazir
what is ohm's law
Pamilerin Reply
states that electric current in a given metallic conductor is directly proportional to the potential difference applied between its end, provided that the temperature of the conductor and other physical factors such as length and cross-sectional area remains constant. mathematically V=IR
ANIEFIOK
hi
Gundala
A body travelling at a velocity of 30ms^-1 in a straight line is brought to rest by application of brakes. if it covers a distance of 100m during this period, find the retardation.
Pamilerin Reply
just use v^2-u^2=2as
Gundala
how often does electrolyte emits?
alhassan
just use +€^3.7°√π%-4¢•∆¥%
v^2-u^2=2as v=0,u=30,s=100 -30^2=2a*100 -900=200a a=-900/200 a=-4.5m/s^2
akinyemi
what is distribution of trade
Grace Reply
what's acceleration
Joshua Reply
The change in position of an object with respect to time
Mfizi
Acceleration is velocity all over time
Pamilerin
hi
Stephen
It's not It's the change of velocity relative to time
Laura
Velocity is the change of position relative to time
Laura
acceleration it is the rate of change in velocity with time
Stephen
acceleration is change in velocity per rate of time
Noara
what is ohm's law
Stephen
Ohm's law is related to resistance by which volatge is the multiplication of current and resistance ( U=RI)
Laura
acceleration is the rate of change. of displacement with time.
Radical
the rate of change of velocity is called acceleration
Asma
how i don understand
Willam Reply
how do I access the Multiple Choice Questions? the button never works and the essay one doesn't either
Savannah Reply
How do you determine the magnitude of force
Peace Reply
mass × acceleration OR Work done ÷ distance
Seema
Which eye defect is corrected by a lens having different curvatures in two perpendicular directions?
Valentina Reply
acute astigmatism?
Practice Key Terms 3

Get the best College physics course in your pocket!





Source:  OpenStax, College physics. OpenStax CNX. Jul 27, 2015 Download for free at http://legacy.cnx.org/content/col11406/1.9
Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google Inc.

Notification Switch

Would you like to follow the 'College physics' conversation and receive update notifications?

Ask