# 7.1 The coordinated max-median rule for portfolio selection  (Page 6/6)

 Page 6 / 6

More often than not, we observed a positive correlation for the years inspected (the strongest correlations are those shown in the figures below). It turns out that for certain years (those with a negative correlation), we ought to utilize the “min-median” as a selection criterion. However, this cannot be known ex-ante , and the best we can do is utilize a measure that more often than not, produces above-average results. Here again, we can appreciate how these conflicting effects would average-out with time in a favorable direction, reiterating the fact that a strategy such as this one, if considered, should be evaluated over the long-haul.

Lastly, several evaluations were performed comparing the various max-medians of the portfolios simulated as a function of the number of portfolios run (i.e. J ) and compared to the single-stock max-median (See Figure 6 below), which could, at least heuristically, serve as an upper bound. This resulted (empirically) to be somewhat unstable as there is no guarantee that any thresholds set in terms of percentage to the bound could be attained in any reasonable computing time, mainly due to the fact the after a reasonable amount of simulations (namely $J=500,000$ and up to $J=2,000,000$ ) the percentages of this single-stock max-median attained depended considerably on the year inspected, making a generalization impossible. The most recent evaluations were performed with stopping after 5 ticks past $J=10,000$ simulations, which seems stable, however based on aforementioned results it seems to not provide any incremental benefit when contrasted to, for instance a hard-coded constant J stopping rule.

## Future directions

Several items are open at this point that might be worthwhile investigating in future research. Amongst them are the following (to mention a few):

1. The identification and investigation of any exogenous variables contributing to any observable associations between current-year portfolio medians and next-year portfolio performances. This is of particular interest as it would provide us with the possibility of meaningfully modifying the simple-criterion to make more informed decisions based on empirical evidence.
2. Considering data from previous years to make the decision at a given year (rather than only considering data from the previous year) as well as investigating any robust-type interpolations (e.g. median or quantile related regression methods).
3. Assessing the reproducibility of the procedure (or in general its performance) in other markets (international) and or other indexes (S&P 100, Russel 1000, NASDAQ, etc.)
4. Investigating a more meaningful rule regarding when to stop the random-search, and how it relates to overall procedure performance.

## Conclusions

In this module, we have presented the details of a modified version of the existing Max-Median Rule allowing for the joint selection of securities within this long-term investment strategy. This modified rule, namely the Coordinated Max-Median Rule , essentially bases the median selection criterion on the joint portfolio performance, rather than on single-stock individual performances. We saw that these modifications came with a cost of increased combinatorial complexity and that due to the impossibility of evaluating all potentially-investible portfolios, a parallelized computational approach had to be considered to assess a satisfactory number of portfolios on a yearly basis for potential investment. The algorithm's implementation was discussed, and several conclusions were drawn, the most significant being that our modified algorithm, much more often than not, seems to out-perform the market (in terms of the S&P 500 Index) when a disciplined investor adheres to it for a reasonable amount of time. The data suggest that one of the contributing factors for this on-average higher performance, at least in part, are the correlations between current year portfolio medians and next year portfolio performance, which seem both weak and not always positive. We noted that, more often than not, these correlations tend to be positive, an effect that seemingly averages out in a positive direction over the long-haul. We have also evaluated the performance of the described procedure on real-world S&P 500 data consisting of 43 years, and several potential future improvements, such as further work regarding a more robust stopping rule and the assessment of the procedure reproducibility with other indexes and or markets, were discussed.

## Acknowledgements

Special thanks are given to Drs. James Thompson and Scott Baggett, as well as to Drs. Linda Driskill and Tracy Volz, for their overall help and coaching throughout this summer research project. In particular special thanks are given to both the NSF and VIGRE for making this research a reality.

## Bibliography

1. O'Shaughnessy, James P. (2003). What Works on Wall Street. A Guide to the Best-Performing Investment Strategies of All Time (Third Edition).
2. Thompson, James R., Baggett, L. Scott (2005). Everyman's Max-Median Rule for Portfolio Selection.
3. Thompson, James R., Baggett, L. Scott, Wojciechowski, William C. and Williams, Edward E. (2006). Nobels for Nonsense. The Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, Fall, pp. 3-18.
4. Wharton Research Data Services (URL: http://wrds.wharton.upenn.edu/)
5. Rossini, A., Tierney, L., and Li, N. (2003). Simple parallel statistical computing. in R. UW Biostatistics working paper series, Paper 193, University of Washington.
6. Tierney, L., Rossini, A., Li, N., and Sevcikova, H. (2004). The snow Package: Simple Network of Workstations. Version 0.2-1.
7. Knaus, Jochen (2008). Developing parallel programs using snowfall

#### Questions & Answers

What is the law of demand
Yaw Reply
price increase demand decrease...price decrease demand increase
Mujahid
ıf the price increase the demand decrease and if the demand increase the price decrease
MUBARAK
all other things being equal, an increase in demand causes a decrease in supply and vice versa
SETHUAH
yah
Johnson
how is the economy of usa now
Johnson
What is demand
jude Reply
Demand is the quantity of goods and services a consumer is willing and able to purchase at various prices over a given period of time.
Yaw
yea
SETHUAH
Okay congratulations I'll join you guys later .
Aj
yes
MUBARAK
calculate elasticity of income exercises
HABANABAKIZE Reply
If potatoes cost Jane $1 per kilogram and she has$5 that could possibly spend on potatoes or other items. If she feels that the first kilogram of potatoes is worth $1.50, the second kilogram is worth$1.14, the third is worth $1.05 and subsequent kilograms are worth$0.30, how many kilograms of potatoes will she purchase? What if she only had $2 to spend? Susan Reply cause of poverty in urban DAVY Reply QI: (A) Asume the following cost data are for a purely competitive producer: At a product price Of$56. will this firm produce in the short run? Why Why not? If it is preferable to produce, what will be the profit-maximizing Or loss-minimizing Output? Explain. What economic profit or loss will the
Falak Reply
what is money
DAVY Reply
money is any asset that is generally acceptable for the exchange of goods and for the settlement of debts
Mnoko
what is economic
Stephen Reply
economics is the study of ways in which people use resources to satisfy their wants
Falak
what is Price mechanism
Dhany Reply
what is Economics
ERNESTINA
The study of resource allocation,distribution and consumption.
Emelyn
introduction to economics
Uday Reply
welfare definition of economics
Uday
examine the wealth and welfare definitions of economics
Uday
read book by ml jhingan
Anand
What do we mean by Asian tigers
Aeesha Reply
Dm me I will tell u
Shailendra
Hi
Aeesha
hi
Pixel
What is Average revenue
KEMZO
How are u doing
KEMZO
it is so fantastic
metasebia
uday
Uday
it is a group of 4 countries named Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong because their economies are growing very faster
Anand
fyn
EDWARD
Please, average revenue is an amount of money you gained after deducted your total expenditure from your total income.
EDWARD
what's a demand
Edward Reply
it is the quantity of commodities that consumers are willing and able to purchase at particular prices and at a given time
Munanag
quantity of commodities dgat consumers are willing to pat at particular price
Omed
demand depends upon 2 things 1wish to buy 2 have purchasing power of that deserving commodity except any from both can't be said demand.
Bashir
Demand is a various quantity of a commodities that a consumer is willing and able to buy at a particular price within a given period of time. All other things been equal.
Vedzi
State the law of demand
Vedzi
The desire to get something is called demand.
Mahabuba
what is the use of something should pay for its opportunity foregone to indicate?
Random Reply
Why in monopoly does the firm maximize profits when its marginal revenue equals marginal cost
astrid Reply
different between economic n history
Falma Reply
A soccer field is a rectangle 130 meters wide and 110 meters long. The coach asks players to run from one corner to the other corner diagonally across. What is that distance, to the nearest tenths place.
Kimberly Reply
Jeannette has $5 and$10 bills in her wallet. The number of fives is three more than six times the number of tens. Let t represent the number of tens. Write an expression for the number of fives.
August Reply
What is the expressiin for seven less than four times the number of nickels
Leonardo Reply
How do i figure this problem out.
how do you translate this in Algebraic Expressions
linda Reply
why surface tension is zero at critical temperature
Shanjida
I think if critical temperature denote high temperature then a liquid stats boils that time the water stats to evaporate so some moles of h2o to up and due to high temp the bonding break they have low density so it can be a reason
s.
Need to simplify the expresin. 3/7 (x+y)-1/7 (x-1)=
Crystal Reply
. After 3 months on a diet, Lisa had lost 12% of her original weight. She lost 21 pounds. What was Lisa's original weight?
Chris Reply
Got questions? Join the online conversation and get instant answers!
Jobilize.com Reply

### Read also:

#### Get Jobilize Job Search Mobile App in your pocket Now!

Source:  OpenStax, The art of the pfug. OpenStax CNX. Jun 05, 2013 Download for free at http://cnx.org/content/col10523/1.34
Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google Inc.

Notification Switch

Would you like to follow the 'The art of the pfug' conversation and receive update notifications?

 By Wey Hey By Subramanian Divya By Mistry Bhavesh By Mariah Hauptman By OpenStax By Jessica Collett By By CB Biern By Jazzycazz Jackson By Olivia D'Ambrogio